понедельник, 12 марта 2012 г.

PNC and Fleet: Necessary merger?

As merger mania runs rampant through the banking world and analysts look for the next logical candidates to join forces, all eyes in the Northeast are turning to PNC Bank Corp. and Fleet Financial Group.

Market watchers say the two banks have a number of reasons to consider a merger. First, they could protect themselves from a takeover offer from an even larger bank by creating a bank with more than $40 billion in market capital.

In addition, the banks combined would cover the entire Northeast region of the United States, with Pittsburgh-based PNC one of the largest regional retail banks in the mid-Atlantic region from Kentucky to New Jersey. Fleet, meanwhile, is a regional retail powerhouse based in New England, with branches down to New York and New Jersey.

Finally, PNC and Fleet could enlarge their already significant retail and mortgage-banking operations by combining forces.

"If your benchmark is market capitalization, PNC is a little bit smaller than Fleet," said Thomas Theurkauf, a bank analyst with Keefe Bruyette & Woods Inc. in New York City. "But the difference is not so great that you couldn't work that out. And there is a logic to combining Fleet and PNC."

Arnold Danielson of Danielson Associates in Rockville, Md., pointed out that the logic of a PNC-Fleet merger became even more apparent after April 13, when Bank of America and NationsBank announced they are coming together in a merger. That mega-merger will cover the entire country except the Northeast and Ohio, so the banks may look into filling that gap, Danielson said.

"When they fill in their merger, the best coverage for filling in that gap is Fleet and PNC," he said. "These two institutions are logical for a takeover."

As Bank of America and NationsBank prepare their own merger, Fleet and PNC would have a six-month window to look at merging with one another before the bigger bank eats them up, Danielson said.

"So, one way out of the thing would be for Fleet and PNC to merge," he said, adding that a PNC-Fleet merger would create the nation's sixth-largest bank in terms of capital.

But if Fleet gets bought by First Union, Danielson said, then PNC would be a target for Bank of America. "So people think if Fleet and PNC aren't talking, they ought to be," Danielson said. "That's the source of the merger rumors."

Indeed, merger rumors abounded all last week, with the banks' stock gyrating as market talk persisted. Shares of both Fleet and PNC fell -- along with those of Mellon Bank, Bank of New York, KeyCorp and BankBoston -- after a Wall Street Journal article that said Fleet was looking at those banks as potential merger partners.

"We don't comment on rumors," said Tim Connolly, a spokesman for Fleet Bank. "We don't encourage that kind of speculation or rumor. As a matter of policy we don't comment on it," said Jonathan Williams, vice president of media relations for PNC.

PNC's Chairman and CEO Thomas O'Brien did address the rumor frenzy at the bank's April 28 annual meeting, when he stated that no merger offers were on the table. O'Brien also said PNC was going to remain headquartered in Pittsburgh, noting that Pittsburgh did not need to lose another headquarters company.

Still, O'Brien admitted a merger could not be ruled out definitively. And Fleet CEO Terrence Murray has made it known that he wants his bank to merge with another regional bank.

To be sure, talk is one thing and action is another.

"There are rumors out there proposing every possible combination," said Robert Swanton, director in the financial institutions group at Standard & Poor's rating agency in New York. "But there are a lot of good fits out there that won't get done."

Having said that, Swanton did point to the natural affinities between the two banks. Fleet has one of the largest mortgage-banking operations in the country, he said, and the bank recently acquired the credit-card operations of Advanta Corp., making it one of the largest credit-card issuers in the country. Fleet has also acquired Quick & Reilly, one of the largest discount brokerages in the country.

PNC, on the other hand, owns one of the largest bank-owned asset managers in the country "and is a significant national corporate banker," Swanton said. Plus, they've developed special expertise in the commercial real estate servicing business with their acquisitions of Black Rock, Midland Loan Servicing and Sears Mortgage.

"So you've got these two players that have got some overlapping, some adjacent and some complementary skill sets. And that's what I think leads people to believe that it would be what they call a good fit," Swanton said.

"Within the regions, PNC and Fleet both a very well diversified," he added. "They have great market positions in their retail bank operations. They're both one or two in their relative markets, and they have a number of diversified businesses. The question becomes, would the two combined become even better?"

Robert Caplan, a bank-equities analyst with FMA Advisory Inc. in Harrisburg, said at this point a Fleet merger would be defensive.

First Union's recent acquisition of Philadephia-based CoreStates has given the Charlotte-based bank a significant market share from Florida to South Jersey, Caplan said. First Union's move into the Northeast would thus be accomplished by acquiring Fleet.

"It would be a quick way to take out the whole East Coast," Caplan said. "If Fleet were to merge with PNC, First Union wouldn't consider Fleet to be so attractive. There would be a lot of anti-trust issues in Pennsylvania."

Perhaps the biggest obstacle to a merger, said Theurkauf of Keefe Bruyette, would be a clash of corporate cultures.

"The tougher part is that making this deal work (involves) cultural issues," Theurkauf said. "Who's going to run the bank? What's it going to be called? Where will it be headquartered?"

Plus, Pennsylvania's anti-takeover laws could make a merger particularly tough for Fleet and PNC, Theurkauf said. "As we were reminded with Mellon Bank and the Bank of New York, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania's laws on mergers and business combinations are stringent," he said.

The Bank of New York, which had earlier been in friendly merger talks with Mellon, made a hostile bid for the bank on April 22. Mellon responded with a lawsuit against BONY, in which it invoked the Pennsylvania anti-takeover law's protection of community interests as a line of defense.

"If Fleet could do it, they would do it. But it wouldn't be easy," Theurkauf said. "There's only room for one CEO, one location. These things are difficult to nail down. But one thing I've learned as an analyst in these last few months is never rule anything out."

Комментариев нет:

Отправить комментарий